ROCKVILLE, Md. — Montgomery County police chief nominee Antonio DeVaul is defending himself against a 2017 fraud finding by calling a vendor-paid trip an accounting oversight. The fraud finding, however, wasn't about the money. It was about DeVaul deliberately trying to conceal his attendance at the conference and who paid for it, auditors determined.
“Chief DeVaul purposely tried to influence the result of the audit in an attempt to conceal expo attendance and compensation from Grainger,” concluded the Maryland-National Capital Park and Planning Commission's Office of Internal Audit in its July 25, 2017, report.
The investigation concerned a February 2015 law enforcement exposition in Orlando, Florida, attended by DeVaul and other Park Police employees. Their expenses were covered by W.W. Grainger Inc., a vendor from which the department purchased nearly $50,000 in equipment and supplies during fiscal 2016.
When auditors questioned DeVaul in June 2017, he initially indicated that he did not believe anyone had attended. After checking his calendar, he stated, “It doesn't look like I was away at conference in February 2015.” He also reported that his 2015 email files were missing. Inspectors tried to “jog his memory” by mentioning a Grainger-provided golf cart made available to a team member who had recent back surgery. DeVaul reiterated his belief that no one attended.
Maryland-National Capital Park and Planning Commission, Office of Internal Audit, Fraud, Waste, and Abuse Audit Report (MC-006-2017-A), July 25, 2017, Page 19.
A month later, on July 5, 2017, Grainger responded to an OIA request and confirmed DeVaul and at least five others attended. Following Grainger's response, DeVaul called investigators and said he now remembered the event. On that call and in an email sent July 6, DeVaul said the Grainger conference was to be paid for by an outside security company that doesn’t do business with MNCPPC, but no one could immediately recall who it was. Once again, Grainger filled in the missing pieces, telling investigators two weeks later that eight attendees, including DeVaul, “selected that Grainger could pay for their registration fee, hotel and air.” No outside security company paid for the trip.
Maryland-National Capital Park and Planning Commission, Office of Internal Audit, Fraud, Waste, and Abuse Audit Report (MC-006-2017-A), July 25, 2017, Page 20.
The auditors concluded that DeVaul's explanations, combined with his prior knowledge of restrictions on vendor-funded travel, supported a finding of fraud under commission policy. They separately found that accepting Grainger-funded expenses in 2015 and 2016 violated purchasing and ethics rules, and that providing training to the vendor constituted abuse of official authority.
In interviews this week with FOX 5 and The Baltimore Banner, DeVaul characterized the payment issue as an oversight and questioned what he could have gained from the arrangement. He also attributed the investigation to retaliation for supporting officers who had alleged discrimination. The initial complaint to OIA may very well have been retaliatory. They certainly knew DeVaul’s vulnerabilities. Nonetheless, the facts in the matter stood up to scrutiny DeVaul tried to evade. He may not have had much to gain from Grainger or the conference, but he had plenty to gain if the investigation cleared his name.
DeVaul also claimed this week that two law firms subsequently investigated the allegations for the City of Takoma Park and cleared him of wrongdoing. County Executive-elect Will Jawando told FOX 5, “I've seen subsequent investigations that have cleared him, and we are happy to make those available as long as there's no legal reason we can't.” As of Thursday, however, none of those purported reports has been publicly released, and our recent request for the documents from the City of Takoma Park remains without response. Neither Jawando nor DeVaul has identified the law firms, provided the dates or scope of their investigations, or disclosed their specific findings.
The conference controversy isn’t the only one DeVaul is facing. This week he also denied directing command staff to falsify payroll records when questioned by The Banner, despite a separate 2018 inspector general's report concluding that he instructed employees to falsify their timecards. The matter was referred to the Montgomery County State's Attorney's Office, but it declined to pursue criminal charges. There are other controversies he has yet to publicly address, including an independent workplace investigation that documented favoritism, harassment, retaliation and a hostile work environment under his leadership, as well as a racially offensive 2015 email he circulated depicting masked Latina women with guns and invoking Wheaton in its subject line.
An August 2015 email sent by Park Police Chief Antonio DeVaul, later entered as evidence in a federal employment discrimination lawsuit.
The questions are mounting. They concern not only DeVaul's explanations, but what Jawando knew, what he reviewed and why the purported exonerating reports remain out of sight. ABC7 reported that when its journalists tried to question Jawando on Wednesday, his security team ushered him away.
So often it’s not about the deed, but the response to it. Richard Nixon’s presidency collapsed because of the cover-up, not the break-in. Bill Clinton was impeached for perjury and obstruction of justice, not the affair. Auditors found fraud in DeVaul’s deliberate attempt to conceal his attendance and who paid for it, not in Grainger paying the bill. And that's the finding DeVaul has yet to explain.
Maryland-National Capital Park and Planning Commission, Office of Internal Audit, Fraud, Waste, and Abuse Audit Report (MC-006-2017-A), July 25, 2017, Page 22.

