County Executive-elect Will Jawando announced Monday his selection of Takoma Park Police Chief Antonio DeVaul to lead the Montgomery County Police Department. (Photo: Will Jawando/Facebook)
ROCKVILLE, Md. — “Those who lead the department must exercise that authority with the highest levels of integrity, accountability and sound judgment,” Montgomery County Executive-elect Will Jawando declared Sept. 18, following an investigation that found Police Chief Marc Yamada had provided false information about selecting his son to accompany him to a conference in Las Vegas.
Two months later, Jawando has selected a successor whose own record includes an internal audit concluding that he attempted to conceal his attendance at a vendor-funded conference in Orlando, instructions to subordinates to falsify official timekeeping records, and findings of favoritism involving Lt. Codi Evans, a friend and subordinate whom investigators later found had falsified timecards and improperly received $676.61 in wages.
The findings concern Antonio “Tony” DeVaul, the former Maryland-National Capital Park Police chief whom Jawando intends to nominate to lead approximately 1,100 Montgomery County police officers.
FOX 5 DC reported Tuesday that Jawando knew about the 2017 fraud investigation before announcing his selection. “I’ve seen subsequent investigations that have cleared him, and we are happy to make those available as long as there’s no legal reason we can’t,” Jawando said. “But we checked through all of this. I’m aware of this FOIA. We talked about it with Chief DeVaul.”
The investigative reports obtained by Montgomery Fix, however, contain unusually direct conclusions about DeVaul’s conduct and leadership. They include findings by the commission’s Office of Internal Audit, Office of Inspector General and an independent human resources consulting firm.
“Chief DeVaul purposely tried to influence the result of the audit”
The July 25, 2017, report investigated a February 2015 trip by DeVaul and other Park Police employees to an exposition in Orlando hosted by W.W. Grainger Inc., a supplier from which the department purchased $49,283.69 in equipment and supplies during fiscal 2016.
The commission had previously warned against allowing Grainger to pay employees’ travel expenses because of the potential conflict of interest. DeVaul knew of the restriction, having reimbursed the vendor $2,551.73 for expenses associated with an earlier conference.
Yet investigators determined that Grainger paid expenses for Park Police employees attending the 2015 event.
When auditors initially questioned DeVaul about the trip in June 2017, he checked his electronic calendar and reportedly stated, “It doesn’t look like I was away at conference in February 2015.”
Grainger subsequently confirmed that he attended.
DeVaul then maintained that an outside security company had paid for police personnel to attend because Park Police officers provided active-shooter training at the exposition. Investigators could not identify that company and ultimately established that the training had actually been conducted for Grainger in Annapolis Junction, Maryland, 11 months earlier. The auditors concluded that the department’s provision of that training to a vendor met the commission’s definition of abuse.
After investigators questioned the arrangements, DeVaul wrote that the department could reimburse Grainger for any unbilled expenses. “I can assure you that there was no intent by any park police staff to violate commission practice 2-24,” he wrote.
The auditors reached a different conclusion.
“Based on the above definition of fraud, the OIA reasonably concludes Chief DeVaul’s actions support a conclusion of fraud,” the report stated. It continued: “Chief DeVaul purposely tried to influence the result of the audit in an attempt to conceal expo attendance and compensation from Grainger.”
The fraud finding was made under commission administrative policies. The report does not establish that DeVaul was criminally charged or convicted.
The same audit also found that DeVaul approved Evans’ acceptance of $529.96 in test equipment from Grainger after the items had been ordered returned. Investigators concluded that the equipment was originally obtained for personal use, that its acceptance violated commission ethics rules and that DeVaul’s subsequent approval supported claims of disparate treatment.
Fraud and Concealment: A July 2017 M-NCPPC internal audit concluded that DeVaul attempted to conceal vendor-paid travel and that his actions supported a finding of fraud under commission policy.
“Chief DeVaul instructed his Command Staff to falsify their time cards”
Another investigation, completed in April 2018, examined widespread timekeeping irregularities among Park Police commanders.
Investigators found that command staff were recording eight-hour workdays without necessarily recording their actual hours worked.
DeVaul acknowledged that his command staff had been told to enter eight hours per day, except for approved overtime. He maintained that the practice was longstanding.
The inspector general contacted Prince George’s County Park Police Chief Stanley Johnson, who reported that his command staff recorded their actual working hours.
The report’s conclusion was direct: “Chief DeVaul instructed his Command Staff to falsify their time cards.” Investigators found the problems pervasive and attributed them primarily to “tone at the top.” They also concluded: “Based on the results of this investigation, the OIG reasonably concludes, inaccurate time reporting is intentional.”
In its findings concerning DeVaul personally, the inspector general again concluded that he had instructed command staff to falsify commission records. However, investigators determined that his own conduct did not meet the commission’s definition of fraud, waste or abuse.
They reached a more severe conclusion concerning Evans, finding that he falsified timecards and improperly received $676.61 in wages, actions that met the commission’s definition of fraud.
Falsified Timecards: An April 2018 inspector general report concluded that DeVaul instructed Park Police command staff to falsify their timecards, although his conduct was not classified as fraud under commission policy.
“He would manipulate people and situations to get the results that he wanted”
An independent investigation by HRX Systems LLC offered an equally critical assessment of DeVaul’s leadership. After interviewing 15 employees, investigators concluded that his management style had emphasized power and organizational politics at the expense of departmental operations.
“He would manipulate people and situations to get the results that he wanted,” the report stated.
“It diverted people’s energy from police work, destroyed morale, and interfered with cooperation and information sharing among the police force.” The investigators described the resulting environment as one of “conflict, distrust, and chaos.”
Investigators identified two competing factions among commanders, one closely associated with DeVaul and Evans. They reported that Evans’ close personal friendship with the chief was widely perceived as providing preferential access, favorable assignments and promotional advantages.
They described “significant favoritism either perceived or actual” and warned of an “underlying culture of favoritism, harassment, and retaliation which creates a hostile workplace.”
The investigators acknowledged that they had not separately investigated individual retaliation allegations. Nevertheless, they attributed the department’s dysfunctional culture to a “top down leadership style that does not promote fairness, mutual respect for coworkers or practice strong human resources policies.”
Manipulation and Favoritism: A June 2018 independent investigation by HRX Systems concluded that DeVaul's management style involved manipulation, damaged morale and fostered conflict and distrust within Park Police.
A negotiated departure and protection from disciplinary charges
The records also include a six-page Settlement Agreement and General Release, signed by DeVaul on Sept. 25, 2017, exactly two months after the commission’s fraud finding.
The document states that disputes arose during DeVaul’s employment and that the parties wished to end their relationship amicably. It provides for DeVaul to announce his retirement by Oct. 1, retire effective Feb. 1, 2018, and be placed on administrative leave beginning Dec. 1, 2017.
Under its terms, the commission would refrain from bringing charges against DeVaul arising from certain existing matters that could otherwise lead to disciplinary proceedings. The agreement also contains confidentiality provisions and a broad release of claims.
The copy reviewed by Montgomery Fix bears DeVaul’s signature but does not include the commission’s countersignature. It therefore does not independently establish that the agreement became fully binding. Its specified retirement date, however, matches his subsequent departure from Park Police.
The records do not establish whether the July 2017 fraud finding prompted the proposed agreement or whether DeVaul faced termination if he declined to retire.
What exactly cleared DeVaul?
Following FOX 5’s reporting, Jawando defended his selection, saying that subsequent investigations cleared DeVaul and offering to make them available if legally permissible.
The subsequently completed reports reviewed by Montgomery Fix contain additional adverse findings, including the inspector general’s conclusion concerning falsified timekeeping instructions, the finding of fraud by Evans and HRX’s criticism of DeVaul’s leadership. Neither report overturns the separate July 2017 finding that DeVaul attempted to influence an audit and that his conduct supported a conclusion of fraud.
The records also contain findings favorable to DeVaul or his subordinates. The 2017 audit found six of nine allegations unsubstantiated. The 2018 timekeeping investigation expressly concluded that DeVaul’s instructions did not meet the administrative definition of fraud, waste or abuse.
The extent to which Jawando’s claimed exculpatory investigations address the separate 2017 fraud finding remains unknown.
Councilmember Dawn Luedtke emphasized the seriousness of the documented findings in comments to FOX 5.
“I want to be clear it was more than just allegations. There were three findings,” Luedtke said.
Council President Natali Fani-González also expressed concerns, saying she believed the Montgomery County Police Department already had qualified personnel of good moral character who did not bring comparable baggage to the position.
Jawando’s own standard
When Yamada resigned, Jawando said rank-and-file officers “deserve leadership that meets those same standards.”
Two months later, Jawando is asking the County Council to confirm a nominee whose previous employer’s investigators concluded that he attempted to influence an audit, instructed subordinates to falsify timekeeping records, approved vendor-provided equipment for a favored subordinate after its acceptance had been challenged, and presided over a department marked by favoritism and retaliation.
The standard Jawando articulated in September was unequivocal. Whether he and the County Council apply that standard to his own nominee is now the central question.
# # #
Sources
M-NCPPC Office of Internal Audit: Fraud, Waste and Abuse Report, MC-006-2017-A, July 25, 2017, particularly report pages 9–10, 18–22 and 24.
M-NCPPC Office of Inspector General: Fraud, Waste and Abuse Audit Report, MC-003-2018-A, April 2018, particularly report pages 16–19.
HRX Systems LLC: M-NCPPC Park Police Workplace Investigation, June 13, 2018.
Settlement Agreement and General Release: Copy signed by Antonio DeVaul, Sept. 25, 2017.
FOX 5 DC: Montgomery County police chief pick faces scrutiny over 2017 fraud probe, Tom Fitzgerald, Nov. 17, 2026.
The Baltimore Banner: Montgomery County Police Chief Marc Yamada resigns, Sept. 18, 2026, including Jawando’s statement.
The Washington Post: Montgomery County police chief resigns after investigation into Vegas trip, Sept. 18, 2026.

