An August 2015 email sent by Park Police Chief Antonio DeVaul, later entered as evidence in a federal employment discrimination lawsuit.
ROCKVILLE, Md. — An August 2015 email sent by then-Maryland-National Capital Park Police Chief Antonio "Tony" DeVaul contained a photograph of four women posing in a vintage lowrider automobile, two wearing bandanas over their faces and displaying what appear to be handguns. Its subject line read, “Girls (Patty) in the hood. Don't mess with Wheeeeeetoon!” The email, sent to DeVaul's executive assistant, Patricia “Patty” Duvall, and Park Police Capt. Darin Uhrig, was subsequently introduced as evidence in a federal employment discrimination lawsuit involving the department.
The photograph originated in 2011 from photographer Guillermo “Memo” Ortega, whose work documents Chicano street life and Southern California lowrider culture. The image has no established connection to Wheaton, but DeVaul's accompanying language apparently invoked stereotypes about the area's Latino community. It is unclear whether the parenthetical reference to “Patty” in the subject line refers to his executive assistant or something else. In a 2023 federal court opinion, the judge described the women as appearing to be Latina and noted that the email's subject line might refer to Wheaton's Latino community.
The email and other records documenting workplace controversies during DeVaul's leadership of Park Police could face renewed scrutiny following County Executive-elect Will Jawando's announcement Monday that he intends to nominate DeVaul as Montgomery County's next police chief. DeVaul, who has led the Takoma Park Police Department since 2018, would oversee approximately 1,100 county officers if confirmed by the County Council.
The federal court records reveal that nearly nine months after sending the email, DeVaul approved an internal affairs investigation that sustained an allegation of inappropriate electronic communications against Capt. Darin Uhrig, one of the recipients of DeVaul's 2015 email. The investigation found that offensive material had been transmitted through the commission's email system, violating a policy prohibiting racially, ethnically or otherwise disparaging communications. DeVaul's signed approval appears on the final page of the 52-page report, dated March 8, 2016, and approved May 12. Consider the implications. DeVaul approved a disciplinary finding against a subordinate for inappropriate electronic communications just months after sending that same officer a photograph with racial implications. Yet the investigation's report makes no mention of the chief's own email or whether his conduct was ever examined under the same standards.
The email was one part of a larger record of management and workplace problems within Park Police during DeVaul's tenure. A June 2018 report by HRX Systems LLC, an independent human resources consulting firm hired by the Maryland-National Capital Park and Planning Commission, described an agency divided into hostile factions, with racial tensions, retaliation and favoritism affecting departmental operations. The investigation followed complaints from nine Park Police officers and included interviews with 15 employees.
“Historically, favoritism was a factor in making promotional decisions,” the HRX investigators wrote. They found that certain officers used internal grievances to obstruct promotions and raised concerns about the chief's broad authority over personnel matters, specifically identifying perceptions of favoritism involving DeVaul's friendship with Lt. Codi Evans. The report warned that the police chief appeared to possess unilateral authority that could lead to misuse of power or retaliation, adding, “This was specifically the perception regarding his friendship with Lt. Codi Evans.” Investigators recommended establishing checks and balances to “prevent the chief from being able to misuse his/her power.”
The HRX investigators also questioned whether senior officers were spending excessive time on internal disputes rather than police responsibilities or mentoring their subordinates. “It seems like officers have a lot of idle time that they spend creating unnecessary issues related to their co-workers,” the report stated. Investigators recommended additional training in workplace sensitivity, harassment prevention and conflict resolution, observing that officers “do not seem to have an understanding of workplace sensitivity, harassment and sexual harassment, conflict resolution, and emotional intelligence.” Their findings portrayed a department in which internal rivalries, inadequate oversight and questionable management practices had become significant organizational problems.
A separate investigation by the commission's Office of Inspector General, completed in April 2018, identified widespread violations of timekeeping requirements among Park Police command staff. According to findings summarized in the federal court opinion, investigators attributed the problems primarily to “tone at the top” and described inconsistent enforcement of rules, intentional inaccuracies in time records and personnel receiving different treatment based on personal alliances. These were failures involving supervision, accountability and the administration of departmental policies, all central responsibilities of the police chief.
The original June 2017 complaint that prompted the HRX investigation provides another perspective on the department's divisions. Its nine signatories expressly supported DeVaul, describing him and another division chief as men of integrity while accusing other supervisors of discrimination and harassment. Among the signatories were Evans and Shibu Philipose, both of whom subsequently joined DeVaul's command staff in Takoma Park in December 2022 as captain and deputy chief, respectively. The independent investigation that followed the officers' complaint nevertheless identified problems with favoritism, retaliation and promotional practices within the department, including concerns specifically involving DeVaul's relationship with Evans.
DeVaul was selected as Takoma Park police chief in December 2017, six months before the HRX investigation was completed. Although the underlying workplace complaints predated his appointment, the investigation's final findings were not available to city officials during their selection process. The inspector general's report was also completed after DeVaul's February 2018 retirement from Park Police.
The records were subsequently introduced as evidence in Evans v. Maryland-National Capital Park & Planning Commission, a federal lawsuit filed in 2019 alleging racial discrimination, retaliation and a hostile work environment. DeVaul was not a defendant. In 2023, the U.S. District Court for Maryland granted summary judgment to the defendants on Evans' remaining claims, a decision subsequently affirmed on appeal. That ruling resolved Evans' legal claims against the defendants. The HRX and inspector general investigations were separate inquiries into departmental operations, and their findings provide an independent record of management practices and workplace conditions during DeVaul's years as chief.
DeVaul served as chief of the Montgomery County Division of Park Police from 2012 until his retirement in February 2018. In announcing his selection, Jawando cited DeVaul's 33 years of law enforcement experience and previous consideration for the county police chief position in 2019. DeVaul emphasized public confidence, declaring that trust must be earned through individual interactions between officers and residents.
The selection has already drawn criticism over the transparency of Jawando's search process. Lee Holland, president of Fraternal Order of Police Lodge 35, told The Baltimore Banner that he had been trying for weeks to meet with Jawando about the selection of a new chief but was unsuccessful. Holland said DeVaul's selection came as a surprise and questioned the absence of a public job announcement and whether internal candidates had been considered. County Councilmember Dawn Luedtke, a member of the Public Safety Committee, also emphasized the need for careful scrutiny, telling The Banner that council members must have an opportunity to interview and thoroughly vet the nominees before voting.
Jawando is expected to formally submit DeVaul's nomination after taking office Dec. 7. The Council will then be asked to entrust him with leadership of approximately 1,100 county police officers. His 2015 email is a matter of record, as are the failures of supervision and accountability documented by independent investigators during his years commanding Park Police. Before handing DeVaul responsibility for Montgomery County's largest law enforcement agency, council members will have to decide whether his record reflects the standards of leadership they expect from its next chief. The responsibility for what happened under his previous command rested with DeVaul. The responsibility for what happens next will rest with the Council.
Sources
U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland: Evans v. Maryland-National Capital Park & Planning Commission, Memorandum Opinion, May 5, 2023, Document 153.
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit: Codi Evans v. Maryland National Capital Parks & Planning Commission, Nov. 21, 2023, No. 23-1475.
Federal court exhibit, ECF 129-19: Antonio DeVaul email dated Aug. 24, 2015, including photograph and subject line. Obtained through PACER, Case No. 8:19-cv-02651.
Federal court exhibit, ECF 128-32: M-NCPPC Park Police internal affairs investigation, dated March 8, 2016, 52 pages, including DeVaul's May 12, 2016, approval. Obtained through PACER.
Federal court exhibit, ECF 128-49: HRX Systems LLC, M-NCPPC Park Police Work Culture Improvement Recommendations, June 13, 2018. Obtained through PACER.
Federal court exhibit, ECF 128-40: June 2017 complaint from nine Park Police officers concerning workplace conduct. Obtained through PACER.

